4 December 2016, Melbourne, Australia
Gabe and Gabi were married just months after Mark’s wife and Gabe’s mother Kerryn died from cancer. She spoke beautifully at their engagement and that is on Speakola.
’When thinking of speaking today, all my family felt it was too hard. They didn’t want to get too sloppy and emotional in public – so I put up my hand and here I am. It’s not everyday that my darling son becomes engaged – autocorrect – married - to the most beautiful girl in the world.’
The problem is, as most of you know, those aren’t my words. They were spoken by Kerryn, who was always the brave one in the family; the one who killed the spiders in our house, stamped on the cockroaches, changed the lightbulbs, took my mother on shopping expeditions, and chased a burglar down the staircase while I hid under the covers.
I’m not here to eulogise Kerryn, but I also can’t leave her to a paragraph of acknowledgment in the middle of a speech, which is why I’ve been accepting those whisky shots even though I can’t stand the taste of hard spirits.
As you know, neither of us believed in souls that live on after death, and while I accept the sentiments of all those who grope for words of comfort, I don’t believe that Kerryn is looking down on us from the heavens, or that we will be reunited any time in the future. But Kerryn’s afterlife has been more powerful than anything I have ever experienced. Those of us who loved her - her children, her siblings and extended family, her friends, and me – her husband – carry her inside us and can’t let go of her. I go to bed at night staring at the emptiness beside me, but conjuring her shape as if she is still there, and then I wake at odd hours, because I feel the covers being tugged to one side, and for a second I think it is her.
There are recurring dreams, some too horrifying to share, but one which I dreamed this week, not for the first time. In it, she is still alive during her illness, and she turns to me and says, Marky, when I die, I want you to plant photographs on my grave. I toy with her and say - and you can plant them in mine too - but she won’t let me get away with it. No really. I negotiate: What about a video? and she shakes her head and so my mind drifts to the mound of earth in the cemetery which me and Gabe visited two weeks ago, covered with photographs from her head to her toes.
In my dream I don’t see the images on the photos, but today, here, now, I can see some of the pictures I would plant. They all come from albums that she herself devised, for even though I am the historian in the family, she was the archivist, and the bearer of our family memories. On holidays, I was always off taking Leica photos of impoverished people in third world countries while her camera was focussed toward the children. That was her – the devoted Mum. So I want to share some of those images that I see, and imagine Kerryn compiling them with me.
1. There is the photo of me and Kerryn taken 33 years ago, plus one week. We are in the gardens of Leonda, it was a hot day like here, everyone was sweating, and we are posed by the photographer with our arms around each other. I look at my bride with love, and it is the start of a marriage. When I look at Gabe and Gabi today, here at Byron Bay, I see the same love that launches a marriage, only they had 8 years to nurture it. I’m so glad that Kerryn got to see your love grow, and while we know that the long road that will last till old age can undulate and become rocky at times, we have always felt that you are the most perfect match. Kerryn used to say as a couples’ therapist that who you love is a choice, but I think there is a part of us that also believed that you two are truly Bashert, fated to be together at the start of a journey of lifelong bliss.
2. I would plant a photo of us at Oxford standing in front of the meadows of Magdalen College in the mid 80s, dressed very pretentiously in tweeds and corduroy. It was the beginning of our dreams. We used to watch ‘Brideshead Revisited’ and imagined an exciting life ahead of us. And it is a blessing I wish for you. You’re both extraordinary kids – I should say adults - Gabe with a law degree and showing the guts to leave the security of his job and throw himself into a start-up, and now getting a job at Mckinsey which will open the most exciting doors for you. And Gabi a doctor like so many in the family, and specialising in radiation oncology. We wish you both, like all of our children, a life that is not staid and boring, but full of risk, wonderment, purpose and growth.
3. This one’s hard. I want a holiday picture. I have more photos than a pack of cards to choose from – the annual pilgrimage to Kibbbutz Seahaven at Noosa, the Club Med holidays with friends where you’d dress up as circus animals or fly on a trapeze or sing Hands Up, photos from palaces in India where you all chanted ‘No More Silly Palaces!’, the sand dunes of the Atlas Mountains in Morocco, treks in Thailand. I know Gabe would want me to choose the one from Kenya where we went on Safari, but I want to choose a photo from a trip in an island off Africa called Llamu where we got sand banked on a dhow, an ancient sailboat, at dusk. Kerryn had broken her leg on the Seychelles island and the only way back to shore was swimming on the shoulders of a couple of local sailors. I remember that photo now because it was one of those moments of terror when we all got separated in the dark, calling out each other’s names, and lived to tell the story. I know how much you love Bondi but I wish you a lifetime of travel, adventure, measured risk, and where you will always protect each other in the dark as well as light.
4. I can’t resist the photo of you Gabe, and Sarah, at Rachel’s batmitzvah – the two of you singing this crazy song, hamming it up and letting yourselves go. It was a moment that only siblings can share, and a memory we will always cherish. What I wish is that as the years go on that all your siblings on both sides – and their partners whoever they choose – do weird and wonderful things together, let the inevitable fights blow over, and share fun times together. Always think back to this year and how you had each other’s backs. Nothing comforted me more this year than sharing laughter, and tears with you all.
5. Then there’s the photo I have to include of you on March of the Living. I have the same photo of each of our kids in successive years – Gabe, Sarah and Rachel, standing at Auschwitz in the same spot where Zaida once stood. We also have a picture of Rachel at Belzec with me, where Buba’s whole town died, leaving her as the only child survivor. You knew you wouldn’t get away without me mentioning the Holocaust but what I want you to remember is that today when we smash the glass, we are reminded of not only the responsibilities that come with carrying the torch of those memories, but the joy and spirit my parents – your Buba and Zaida embodied in defiance of death. Two years ago was the seventieth anniversary of the annual Buchenwald Ball, which more than anything captures what we’ve come to call ‘dancing through our pain.’ Mum became an honorary Buchenwalder through marriage, which makes you one Gabi. At last, you’re a descendant of Holocaust survivors and not just a Lithuanian and South African immigrant. That 70th anniversary was organised table by table by Mum, one month before she was diagnosed with cancer, and will remind us always that our legacy is to always celebrate life and dance through the pain until we find double doses of joy to make up for the sorrow. Like tonight.
6. There are so many other photos. I think of the pictures of you in Israel when we lived there again in 1995, and how after the Second Intifada, we all arrived the day after a bomb went off at a Café on Emek Refaim. I was frozen and didn’t want to leave the hotel, but Mum pushed us to go out and light candles and by the end of the trip, at your insistence Gabe, we left you for a few months at a school while you were in Year Ten. There was something about that moment that made us realise that you’re your own man. I’m proud that all of my kids and Gabi have this love of Israel, even if it’s mainly to the Tel Aviv party life, and as you know, I hope that you express that love through concern for building the best, most just society, not only in Israel, but here in Australia and in other parts of the world.
7. We don’t really take photos of Seders but we’ve got lots of images. So I have to include a picture of us seated as is our custom on the floor, me in the days when I wore a white kittl and did magic tricks to keep you interested, the times we shared each night with the Wollners, Weins, Weins and Bakers. You’re so lucky to have a close set of Aunties and Uncles who would do anything for you, cousins you love; remember, they and your siblings are always there for you, as we say on Pesach, bechol dor vador - in this and all the generations to come.
8. Rabbi Ralph already talked about a picture I would include by tying Mum’s bridal veil on a pole around the chuppa – of me and Mum on Simchat Torah when Mum was Kallat Torah and I was Chattan Torah. Mum learned to read from the Torah the end of the story in Devarim and I would chant the beginning part from Bereishit, joining our ends and beginnings together in one story as we rolled back the Torah scroll. That moment captures not only the fun spirit we had, Mum squeezing into her dress and me into my suit, but through this ritual we re-enacted our marriage, reigniting some of what gets lost in the routines of life, especially when it comes to bringing up kids. We did the same for Buba and Zaida on their 50th wedding anniversary, when we organised a treasure hunt for them in the city, and then dressed them up like a young married couple. Learn from that – how in marriage it’s not just tonight, but if you can, make every day your marriage day and don’t let go of what you are feeling now. Nurture it, and remember: Love means having to say you’re sorry.
9. The next photo is of Gabe’s proposal where he involved the whole family in the process, but the main picture I want to plant is of you Gabi being let out of a car in town. It was raining and we walked up Swanston St, with Kerryn holding your hand, up to Cookies restaurant in the city, and found the same table we’d sat on when you first came out for dinner. You said in your speech I intimidated you – do I still? But we have that most precious photo of the 3 of us, drinking a cocktail, celebrating the Gabi who has come to be part of our family. You’re one of the kids to me now, and you and Kerryn showed so much love and respect for each other. Your parents have been extraordinary to Gabe, providing a second family for him in Sydney. We get to do the same with you at Aroona and on holidays and I promise you, if you do stay in Sydney, once you have kids, I’ve told Karen and Colin that I’ll be in Bondi as often as I can babysitting… and sunbaking.
10. Then there is the photo of us dancing at your engagement after Gabe cried and said, I’ll never be happy again. But look how happy we were then and now. And part of the reason is that as a family we hold each other up – not only on our side, but with the special bond that we’ve all created with Karen and Colin, and how Marlene and Sydney have bonded with Buba and Zaida. I love that you all, Deena and Josh, Sarah and Rachel, with your partners, Matt, Benj and Charlette, are so close. I don’t know about you Josh because you’re in LA marketing Tindr – maybe in a couple of years you can show me how it works. But what I want to emphasise is how lucky we are to have Karen and Colin as our machetunim. Now that’s a new word for me. We just get on so well and I know that the three of us are the village you will need to build a strong home and marriage.
11. There are pictures of us from the past ten months that I want to cherish tonight. The four of us in Byron, running to the lighthouse, searching from farm to farm, until Gabi said, This is it and we knew it was. And then there is the photo of us in Bryon, the four of us sitting on a huge deck chair over the beach, oblivious of the mosquitos that would zone in on me and give me Dengue Fever, and you reading the manuscript of my memoir about Mum, and crying together. What was Hillary’s campaign. Stronger Together. And as much as I hate Trump, We’ll make our lives great again.
12. And then there is this photo, today. Me walking you to the chuppa, you giving a speech Gabe and Gabi with strength and tears. One of the last things me and Mum did was search in the Yarra Valley for the perfect venue. It wasn’t meant to be but those trips we took, with Kerryn barely able to walk out of the car, one with Gabe makes me realise how much she would have loved being here. I will never forget Gabi your strongest desire to marry Gabe under such a dark shadow. The shadow hasn’t lifted but you Gabi and Gabe deserve the best life.
13. The photo that really counts hasn’t been taken yet. It’s blank but I shall plant it. And in the years to come, you will fill it with everything you create together. Grandchildren, dreams realised, bucket lists, and more celebrations. As you all know, our marriage began with a lot of tragedy, but we were lucky to have 32 years of blessings. That is what I wish for you – only bracha, for a life as long as the years of your grandparents may they live till 120.
• Kerryn did have one request. She wanted me to sing a blessing that I used to sing to all of my kids when they were young, and that I sang at Gabe’s barmitzvah. Excuse my voice, but I want to include you in it Gabi. It’s a song that blesses the guardian angels, one of whom is Gavriel. So hard as it is, I will fulfil my vow as a blessing to you. Beshem hashem….
• And I end with the one bracha that breaks my heart, because it is the only thing I cannot share with Kerryn. Please join me in saying it, the prayer in which we show gratitude for being alive to see this day. Baruch ata …sheheyanu, vekimanu vehigiyanu lazman hazeh.
• And now, let’s dance. ROCK AROUND THE CLOCK